Choosing between a CMMC certified MSP and consultant isn’t about cost—it’s about what compliance requires long-term. Many defense contractors think consultant guidance suffices, only to discover CMMC certification demands continuous monitoring and adaptation.
This confusion costs organizations time, money, and DoD contracts. While both play roles in the CMMC ecosystem, understanding their differences helps you choose wisely. This comparison reveals what each offers and why MSP partnership often delivers better results for sustainable compliance.
Related Topic: How to Pick the Perfect CMMC Certified MSP Near You for Your Defense Projects?
What is a CMMC Certified MSP?
Core MSP Capabilities for CMMC Compliance
A managed service provider (MSP) specializing in CMMC compliance delivers comprehensive cybersecurity implementation. These providers manage security for organizations handling controlled unclassified information. An MSP goes beyond consulting by actively managing security infrastructure, monitoring networks continuously, and maintaining compliance documentation.
These providers offer CMMC compliance services including:
- Endpoint protection and device management
- Vulnerability assessments and remediation
- Incident response protocols and execution
- Access control management and monitoring
How MSPs Support Continuous CMMC Requirements
MSPs must understand CMMC requirements to deliver effective cybersecurity services. A service provider supporting CMMC implements continuous monitoring systems that detect threats in real-time. This contrasts sharply with point-in-time assessments.
MSPs in cybersecurity maintain persistent vigilance through:
- Automated threat detection systems
- Regular security updates and patches
- Compliance reporting and documentation
- Policy enforcement across networks
- Ongoing staff training programs
CMMC certified MSPs provide 24/7 threat detection and incident response that consultants cannot deliver in project-based engagements.
MSP Service Delivery Models for Defense Contractors
Defense contractors can engage an MSP through flexible service tiers matching their security maturity and budget. Using an MSP for CMMC Level 2 compliance typically involves:
- Co-managed models: Defense contractors maintain internal IT teams while the MSP handles specialized security functions
- Fully managed models: Complete responsibility transfers to the MSP, ideal for organizations lacking dedicated cybersecurity staff
Service tiers scale from basic monitoring and patch management to comprehensive security operations. Advanced tiers include 24/7 SOC coverage, forensic analysis, and regulatory reporting.
I’ve watched defense contractors learn the hard way: CMMC certification is the beginning, not the destination.
Related Topic: Smart Way to Choose a CMMC Certified MSP
What is a CMMC Consultant?
CMMC Consultant Roles and Responsibilities
A CMMC consultant provides advisory services to organizations navigating their compliance journey toward certification. These professionals conduct gap assessments, develop security policies, and prepare documentation. This prepares organizations for formal evaluation by a CMMC assessor.
A certified CMMC professional brings specialized knowledge of framework requirements, helping organizations understand which controls apply to their operations. Consultants typically deliver project-based services including:
- Gap assessments and readiness evaluations
- Security policy and procedure development
- Compliance documentation preparation
- Employee training programs
- Audit preparation and remediation guidance
Consultant Certification Paths
Becoming a CMMC registered practitioner requires completing accredited training programs and demonstrating knowledge of framework requirements. A certified CMMC assessor holds advanced credentials authorizing them to conduct official evaluations for the Cyber Accreditation Body. These credentials validate expertise in assessment and advisory capabilities rather than implementation.
Typical Consulting Engagement Limitations
CMMC consulting engagements follow defined project phases with clear endpoints. CMMC consultants focus on planning and documentation. They do not provide continuous security operations. The right consultant delivers valuable roadmaps and prepares organizations for assessment. Their compliance project concludes once policies are documented and initial controls are implemented.
Consultants guide organizations through initial CMMC 2.0 certification process stages, but engagement ends before implementation begins.
Consultants have value, but understanding what happens after their final report is critical.
Related Topic: CMMC Certified MSP Near You | Find Trusted Cybersecurity Experts Today
Key Differences Between MSPs and Consultants
Ongoing Management vs. One-Time Project Support
The difference between managed services and consulting centers on engagement duration and ongoing responsibility.
MSP Approach:
- Continuous monitoring and support 24/7
- Long-term partnership throughout compliance lifecycle
- Sustained compliance between audits
Consultant Approach:
- Time-bound engagement with defined end date
- Project-based relationship for specific milestones
- Organization manages operations independently after project
An MSP provides dedicated resources available continuously to address security incidents and update systems. Working with an MSP means having persistent support that ensures organizations sustain compliance. A CMMC compliance consultant delivers valuable initial guidance but typically exits once foundational work concludes.
Hands-On Implementation vs. Advisory Recommendations
The difference between MSP and IT service provider models versus consulting lies in execution responsibility.
Service Provider Implementation:
- Actively implements and configures security controls
- Takes ownership of deploying protections
- Manages ongoing infrastructure and operations
Consultant Recommendations:
- Provides guidance on what should be implemented
- Delivers recommendations and documentation
- Organization locates resources for execution
An external service provider takes hands-on responsibility for implementing CMMC practices, from technical deployment to operational management. Organizations must then locate internal resources or additional vendors to perform actual implementation. This can delay compliance timelines and introduce errors when teams lack specialized cybersecurity expertise.
Related Topic: Why Choosing a CMMC Certified MSP Is a Game-Changer for Your Cybersecurity?
Predictable Investment vs. Project Fee Uncertainty
Cost structures differ significantly based on MSP needs versus consultant engagements.
MSP Pricing:
- Fixed monthly fees for defined scope
- Predictable budget planning
- No surprise costs for standard delivery
Consultant Pricing:
- Estimated project fees subject to change
- Scope expansion increases costs
- Additional requirements discovered during work
MSPs provide financial predictability that helps organizations plan compliance program budgets accurately. Understanding these financial differences helps evaluate total cost of ownership beyond initial engagement fees.
When Your Organization Needs a CMMC Certified MSP
Limited Internal IT and Security Resources
Most defense contractors lack dedicated cybersecurity staff, making an MSP essential to achieve CMMC compliance. Organizations need an MSP when they face:
- No full-time cybersecurity personnel on staff
- Limited IT team bandwidth for security-focused work
- Inability to maintain 24/7 security monitoring
Organizations pursuing CMMC Level 2 certification especially benefit from MSP support. This tier requires sophisticated security capabilities beyond basic IT management. Defense contractors without IT staff benefit from foundational IT management and monitoring as a CMMC compliance foundation.
Need for Continuous CMMC Compliance Maintenance
CMMC compliance requires ongoing commitment. Organizations must maintain compliance through:
- Regular system updates and security patches
- Policy reviews and documentation updates
- Incident response and threat monitoring
MSPs provide the continuous oversight necessary to sustain CMMC compliance between formal assessments. These providers monitor systems constantly, implement security patches promptly, and adjust controls as compliance requirements change. Organizations seeking comprehensive CMMC compliance services benefit from ongoing monitoring, vCISO oversight, and continuous audit readiness.
Complex Multi-Level CMMC Requirements
Organizations progressing through CMMC levels face increasing complexity. As defense contractors pursue higher-value DoD contracts, they must meet CMMC standards appropriate to the controlled unclassified information they handle. Mapping CMMC and NIST 800-171 compliance requirements demonstrates why organizations need ongoing MSP support, not one-time consulting.
If you’re asking ‘who handles this after certification?’ you need an MSP, not a consultant.
Related Topic: CMMC Certified MSP Explained: Everything Businesses Should Know
When a CMMC Consultant Might Be Sufficient
Established IT Team with Strong Security Expertise
Consultants may suffice when defense contractors maintain robust internal IT capabilities. Consultants may be sufficient when organizations have:
- Full-time cybersecurity personnel on staff (not general IT)
- Established security operations center or monitoring capabilities
- Technical staff experienced in DoD frameworks
Internal IT can be better than MSP services when teams possess deep technical expertise and can translate recommendations into functioning controls. Most find resources stretched too thin for both business operations and security requirements.
When Organizations Choose Consultant-Only Approaches
Some organizations initially pursue consultant-only engagements for various reasons. A CMMC level 2 assessment from a consultant can identify deficiencies and document required improvements. However, the CMMC certification process requires persistent technical support beyond advisory services.
Organizations often discover that implementation, continuous monitoring, and sustained compliance between formal audits demand ongoing expertise. Many MSPs now provide comprehensive services from initial gap assessment through certification and continuous maintenance, eliminating the need for multiple providers throughout the compliance journey.
Why Many Organizations Start with Consultants, Then Switch to MSPs
The Limitations Organizations Discover After Consulting Engagements
Limitations become apparent when organizations operationalize consultant recommendations. Common limitations discovered after consulting engagements:
- Documentation without execution – Comprehensive roadmaps but no implementation support
- Resource constraints – Internal staff lacks bandwidth for specialized security work
- Translation challenges – Difficulty converting policies into functioning technical measures
MSPs offering CMMC compliance services bridge this execution gap. Many defense contractors discover common CMMC compliance challenges only after their consultant has departed, leaving them struggling with implementation, documentation gaps, and ongoing monitoring requirements they’re unprepared to handle internally.
Bridging the Gap: From Recommendations to Implementation
The natural progression from consultant to MSP follows a predictable pattern:
Consultant Assessment:
- Conduct gap analysis and identify deficiencies
- Document required controls and policies
MSP Implementation: 3. Implement security controls identified during assessment 4. Deploy monitoring systems and configure infrastructure
CMMC compliance services from an MSP include hands-on remediation that consultants recommend but rarely perform. Organizations with existing IT teams often find success with a co-managed IT services approach, where internal staff handles daily operations while certified MSPs manage CMMC-specific security requirements and compliance monitoring.
The Cost-Benefit Reality of Long-Term Partnerships
Working with an MSP delivers superior value when evaluating total compliance costs over three years.
Consultant Model typically includes:
- Lower upfront cost but higher total ownership
- Internal staff time plus external contractors
- Separate security tool purchases
- Additional monitoring vendor costs
MSP Model typically includes:
- Higher initial investment with predictable monthly fees
- Implementation, tools, and monitoring all included
Organizations must account for internal staff time executing recommendations, security tool purchases, and ongoing monitoring expenses. They also face remediation work before the client’s CMMC assessment. The MSP partnership model reduces risk by ensuring continuous expertise availability throughout the CMMC journey.
Six months post-consultant, companies call saying: ‘we have the plan but need execution.’
Related Topic: How the Benefits of CMMC Certified MSP Protect Businesses?
Making Your Decision: Why MSPs Deliver Better Long-Term Results
Evaluating Your True CMMC Compliance Needs
CMMC difficulty depends on organizational maturity.
Situations pointing to MSP:
- No dedicated security staff
- Require ongoing maintenance
Situations pointing to Consultant:
- One-time gap assessment only
An MSP in cybersecurity provides comprehensive support covering technical implementation, continuous monitoring, and adaptation to evolving threats. Assessing CMMC readiness requires evaluating current gaps and ongoing operational demands. Understanding the full scope of preparing for CMMC as a defense contractor helps reveal whether consultant guidance will suffice or whether comprehensive MSP partnership better addresses your organization’s compliance complexity.
The Hidden Costs of the Consultant Approach
Total consultant ownership costs include:
Total Cost of Consultant Ownership (3-Year Analysis):
- Initial consultant fees – $15,000-$50,000 for gap assessment and roadmap
- Internal staff implementation time – 200-500 hours at $75-150/hour loaded cost
- Security tools and infrastructure – $20,000-$100,000 in technology purchases
- Gap remediation before assessment – $10,000-$40,000 in additional consultant fees
Estimated 3-Year Total: $100,000-$350,000+
The right consultant provides valuable guidance. However, certification ultimately comes from certified CMMC assessors working through the CMMC accreditation body.
Questions to Ask When Choosing Your CMMC Partner
Critical questions help organizations choose an MSP that delivers complete CMMC support:
Implementation & Ongoing Support:
- Will you provide continuous monitoring after initial implementation?
- Can you respond to security incidents requiring immediate containment?
Compliance Achievement:
- How do you help organizations pass a CMMC assessment?
- Do you provide hands-on operational support to comply with CMMC?
Partnership Value:
- How do you adapt to changing compliance requirements?
- Do you have experience with organizations that require CMMC certification?
The real question isn’t ‘MSP or consultant’—it’s when you’ll realize ongoing partnership wins.
Related Topic: How Can AI and Automation Help Future-Proof Your IT Strategy?
Final Thoughts: CMMC Certified MSP vs. Consultant
Both CMMC Certified MSPs and CMMC consultants play essential roles in helping defense contractors achieve and maintain compliance. Consultants shine during the early stages—conducting readiness assessments, identifying gaps, and outlining strategic roadmaps that define the what and why of compliance. Yet, once the consultant’s engagement ends, many organizations find sustaining daily implementation and continuous monitoring to be a significant challenge.
That’s where a CMMC Certified Managed Service Provider (MSP) steps in. MSPs like Right Hand Technology Group go beyond strategy—they execute, monitor, and maintain compliance frameworks in real time. Their proactive management ensures evolving cybersecurity threats are addressed promptly, and that CMMC controls remain active, documented, and audit-ready year-round.
While partnering with an MSP may appear to be a higher upfront investment, the total long-term value—including reduced risk exposure, operational efficiency, and sustained compliance assurance—often surpasses managing everything in-house.
FAQ Section
Do MSPs need to be CMMC certified?
MSPs supporting defense contractors should hold CMMC certification demonstrating commitment to framework standards. This ensures persistent compliance expertise throughout your partnership.
Can a consultant help with initial CMMC assessment then hand off to an MSP?
Yes, this two-phase approach is common. However, many MSPs offer comprehensive initial assessments, eliminating the need for multiple providers.
What happens to my CMMC compliance after a consultant finishes their project?
You’re responsible for maintaining CMMC compliance after consultant departure. Most organizations find MSPs prevent gaps before formal assessment.
How much do CMMC consultants make per hour compared to MSP monthly costs?
Consultants charge $150-350 per hour. MSPs cost $3,000-10,000 monthly but include monitoring, implementation, maintenance, and incident response—delivering greater ongoing value.
Can an MSP handle both CMMC Level 2 certification AND ongoing compliance?
Yes, an MSP provides comprehensive service from initial assessment through CMMC Level 2 certification and continuous maintenance. This achieves CMMC compliance without consultant project limitations.
